Loved it. Simply loved it. No complaints. My emotions were all over the place with Piper's parents though. John wrote them in such a real way that I hated them immensely. Such great character growth occurred in just about everyone though. Well, everyone but Josh. Don't get his deal but I'm glad he ended up where he belonged. Highly recommend. I'm on a band kick lately and can't get enough of these books about bands. This one gets right to the heart of what I love most about music. It really is a universal language.